My image is for 5-6th grade students. They are advanced enough to understand that you need to find the biggest number first (gcf) to simplify fractions. However they do make mistakes which is why I said to repeat the process. I decided to take this concept because the normal visual can get very messy and confusing. Therefore I turned it into a simple circular process to hopefully help out my students.
Section 2: Revised image

Section 3: Usability comments from team partnerSection 4: Original image

Section 5: Justification statements
The process of simplifying fractions can get messy. I decided to use a circle because circles help show process and help beginning learners (pg. 350). I kept the definition of gcf separate because it is only there for people that get stuck in the circle and look for what gcf means. I did not use an arrow for where to start because I thought that it was extraneous material. After adding it, I deleted it due to its distraction. This image is simple, however it still contains complex ideas in it. Therefore, the germane load is increased, and the extraneous load is decreased (pg. 52). In a normal visual of how to simply fractions there is a lot of dividing top and bottom, which gets very distracting. I used the circle in hopes that the information works as a unit and is better chunked together for the working memory to process (pg. 55).
This is a fantastic image for a mathematical concept. I think it is very well executed and it took me a while to come up with some constructive comments, so here it goes: I feel that the "start here" is important and should be kept in the image. Changing that text to an arrow will detract from the existing arrows and the circular flow they describe in the process. I think that the existing arrows are fine the way they are. I also had experimented with arrows in Fireworks and could not manipulate them into a curve that would translate nicely to a circle. I think you did a great job with these and that the idea of a circular flow is clear. I am wondering if you tried the image with the title at top? Just a thought as I tend to prefer titles at the top of instruction. The colors used are great and I see no need to change them. I also think that the size you chose for the text works very well. It may be beneficial to the student if "GCF" was indicated somewhere. If it were me, I would have to write down on the sheet what that stood for because there are days I can't remember anything. Is it greatest common factor? In closing I think that you did a great job on this image. Good work!!